Death in D Minor

Just when you think all the angles a cozy mystery can possibly come from have been covered, some lovely writer like Alexia Gordon comes along with unique characters, a unique setting, and really solid writing. Just when you start rolling your eyes at the idea of another cozy mystery featuring ghosts, Gethsemane Brown comes along in a corner of Ireland I for one have never visited on the page before, with one of the more unusual sidekicks I’ve seen.

This is one of those books I blame for keeping me coming back to the genre. It’s worth it – just about – to wade through all the bad ‘uns just to find the occasional gem like this.

One of the happy aspects of Alexia Gordon’s writing is graceful exposition. Bear with me, because I’m probably going to compliment every author I read who knows how to introduce a character without making her look in the mirror and ponder her past, or who can show Character A catching Character B up on something the latter missed without indulging in Reality-Show-Recap-itis. It seems like it’s becoming more and more rare for writers to avoid the pitfalls, so – praise where it’s due, by all means.

This book can serve as proof that the heroine of a book, or a series, doesn’t have to be warm and cuddly to be absolutely enjoyable. Gethsemane is prickly, not socially comfortable – and very unhappy to find that getting what you asked for doesn’t always mean getting what you want. Hers is the sort of story that makes me hope she doesn’t go through this level of trouble in every book – not because it’s unrealistic or repetitious or anything of the sort, but because of a deep sympathy for her – it’s stressful.

The ghostly secondary character(s) reminded me a bit of The Ghost and Mrs. Muir; I’m not sure if it’s headed in the same direction as that movie (or tv series), but I’m fine with it if it does. And I wouldn’t say that about a lesser series. But this – this was lovely, and I look forward to more.

This book came out in July 2017; the newness of the book may have something to do with the reference to “Ronald Crump”.

And if you don’t like my review, “may the cat eat you, and may the devil eat the cat.” So there. (Not really – I just wanted an excuse to quote that.)

The usual disclaimer: I received this book via Netgalley for review.

This entry was posted in books, mystery and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Death in D Minor

  1. Where is your ‘like’ button? I enjoyed this review. I wanted to let you know. …

  2. stewartry says:

    Heh heh – thank you! The like button should be at the bottom, next to the reblog button; if you hit control-F and look for “like” it’ll turn up. (But don’t feel you have to! :P)

  3. Jane Steen says:

    You’re reading up a storm lately! Or are you getting to your backlog? Either way, it’s nice to hear you’ve found a good series. I’ve dumped so many…pinning some hope on Deanna Raybourn’s latest series, though, and FINALLY read one of Anne Perry’s long-running Victorian detective books and will probably go back and start the series. One day. Because I have 1,000,000 books I need to read first, many for research, and have been struggling with finding reading time.

  4. stewartry says:

    It’s a bit of both! I’m reading at about the same rate, but unfortunately I have a bad habit of taking forever and a day to finish reviews, which is not good for Netgalley. So I’m pushing myself to get ‘er done.

    Enjoy Anne Perry! She’s an old dependable. Not a real absolute knock-people-down-to-get-to-them favorite or anything, but solid.

    How’s England? (she asked longingly)

  5. Jane Steen says:

    My part of England’s very pretty, and has better weather than most other parts of England. The country as a whole is beset with Brexit-related politics, a crap economy and terrorism in about equal measure. But we have pubs! And the BBC! The TV is amazingly good after the US.

  6. stewartry says:

    Where in the world do we have to go to get away from politics, crappy economies, and terrorism? At least you don’t have to listen (or *shudder* look at) to a giant orange toddler on the news day in and day out … That alone would make tv better!

  7. Jane Steen says:

    We change channels when the Cheeto is on. The nice thing is we get all these cool UK channels and quite a few American ones as well. The weird thing is all the journalists and TV personalities who were there 20 years ago and are still there only so much older.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s